For plain broth that has not already been thickened, start with 1 level tablespoon of cornstarch per cup of broth as a recipe reference. If you are rescuing gravy that already coats a spoon a little, mix a smaller amount first and add it in stages. The ratio of starch to gravy and the ratio of starch to cold water answer two different questions.

How much cornstarch for 1, 2 or 4 cups of gravy?
Measure the liquid before heating it. The table scales the one-cup starch amount in Argo’s broth-based gravy recipe. The two- and four-cup rows are arithmetic scaling, so hold some slurry back and adjust while whisking.
| Broth | Cornstarch reference | Same amount in teaspoons |
|---|---|---|
| 1 US cup | 1 tablespoon | 3 teaspoons |
| 2 US cups | 2 tablespoons | 6 teaspoons |
| 4 US cups | 4 tablespoons | 12 teaspoons |
Mix the slurry cold, then add it while whisking
- Reserve a little cool, unthickened broth from the batch, or use cold water. Start with enough to stir the starch into a smooth, pourable mixture. A practical small-batch starting point is equal volumes of cold liquid and starch.
- Warm the remaining gravy base. Stir the slurry again just before adding it because the starch settles quickly.
- Whisk in part of the slurry and let the gravy heat through before judging its thickness. Follow the recipe’s heating instruction and avoid prolonged hard boiling. Stop adding starch when a warm spoon comes out with the coating you want.
How to rescue gravy that is already partly thickened
Suppose you have two cups of thin gravy containing some roux. The table’s two tablespoons describe a batch starting from plain liquid. First whisk one teaspoon of starch into enough cold water to pour easily, add some of that slurry, and check the warm gravy again before adding the rest. This is a cautious trial amount, not a prediction of a fixed final thickness. If the sauce becomes too thick, whisk in a little warm unsalted broth and taste before adding salt.
Gravy that is lumpy needs a different fix. Try whisking or passing it through a fine sieve before deciding if it needs more starch. Iowa State Extension’s gravy guide explains other fixes and why prolonged boiling can thin starch-based gravy. Food Network’s sauce guide also distinguishes equal parts for the slurry from the amount of starch per cup of sauce.